far wrote:i dont think that's hacky grendel, gimme some bulletpoints.
I am not good at explaining stuff and this will all seem banal paraphrasing it, but basically he says that the industrial revolution was a movement which required introducing a "market society" i.e. having all commodities allocated by markets. This off course includes labour (people) and land (nature) which Polanyi calls fictitious commodities as they are not produced in accordance with supply and demand. He says that doing this basically will destroy society and nature, which means that various counter-movements spring up in order to slow down the rate of change initiated by the transformation or fend it off. This can result in unlikely alliances and groups who take the initiative to ward off the change but at the same time benefit from doing so.
Obviously at this point most (all?) of the world is a market society, but people are always a sticky point with this since they fight to keep what they have instead of submitting to being just elements in a labour market that constantly move and adapt to supply market demand. It seems that with AI you can view it as trying to eliminate as many pesky people as possible and have the machine carry it all out. And obviously there will be various groups etc. that try to fight and keep what they have (professional organizations requiring licensing is just one that comes to the top of my mind). Another one is the anti-immigration sentiment that seems to be worldwide right now--market logic demands totally free movement of people to wherever they are most productive but that interacts with nationalism and people wanting to keep others out to protect what they have etc.
The difference being that in the 19th century they were creating a market for labour to force people into the factories (what Polanyi calls the Satanic Mill) whereas with AI it is the opposite and they are trying to make large swathes of the labour market surplus to requirement.
Obviously this is poorly explained and banal but yeah. The actual book itself is a bit of a mixed bag as some parts are kind of poorly expounded upon and I can't speak to the historical accuracy of the examples he uses, but the broad framework of the movement to subsume everything to market logic (and that basically destroying people and nature) and the countermovement to fight or atleast slow down this movement make a lot of sense to me.
Thank you for coming to my TED talk.